What is employee vetting: Steps and best practices
Welcome to our page on employee vetting section. This essential process in human resources allows organizations to thoroughly assess the qualifications, skills, background, and overall suitability of candidates for various roles. It’s crucial for home or office employers to ensure that new hires align not only with the necessary qualifications but also with the company’s culture and values. By doing so, we can minimize risks such as fraud and workplace misconduct, as well as avoid the high CCMA costs associated with bad hires. Explore this page to discover critical steps to employee vetting, best practices, and helpful tools.
01
What is employee vetting?
Employee vetting checks and assesses a candidate’s background, qualifications, work history, criminal record, financial status, and other relevant factors before hiring. This helps ensure that an employer hires the right person for the job. Vetting helps determine whether a candidate can perform the job and if they are trustworthy, reliable, and fit the company culture.
Depending on a company’s specific needs and values, vetting may involve several different types of background checks. Here are the most common categories:
Components of the employee vetting process:
-
Identity verification
-
Financial history checks
-
Educational verification
-
Employment history verification
-
Criminal record checks
02
Why is employee vetting important?
The importance of employee vetting cannot be overstated. Hiring the wrong person can lead to:
-
Increased turnover: Bad hires are more likely to leave or be dismissed, which leads to higher turnover and recruitment costs.
-
Legal issues: Failure to conduct proper background checks may expose the company to lawsuits or regulatory penalties, especially in regulated industries.
-
Workplace safety: Checking whether a prospective employee is not wanted for or has had a criminal record and violent tendencies is fundamental in providing a healthy work environment.
-
Reputation damage: Poor hires can smear your firm’s reputation with their misconduct and inability to perform tasks.
-
Financial losses: Hiring an ill-equipped employee causes errors and delays, leading to ineffectiveness in most operations.
By conducting vetting procedures, you can reduce these risks and ensure they bring on board people who will help contribute positively towards the organizations.
03
Steps to include in the screening process
The employee vetting process involves several key stages to help you determine if a candidate is the right fit for the role and the organization. Each step, from reviewing job descriptions to conducting background checks, is necessary to ensure a complete evaluation. Our paid service will assist any employer from home to office with this process...
1. Job description review
The first thing you should do before starting the vetting process is to make sure that the job description is clear and accurate. It is crucial because it becomes the foundation of your vetting process. A good job description details the skills, qualifications, and experience needed and helps you align your search with the right candidates.
Make sure to include:
-
The responsibilities and duties of the role.
-
Required qualifications, such as education, certifications, and experience.
-
Desired soft skills like communication, leadership, and teamwork.
-
Any necessary technical skills or specialized knowledge.
4. Background checks
A background check is a crucial part of the employee vetting process. Research by The Dainfern Butler indicates that 1 in 4 candidates fail some aspect of a background check, whether criminal history, employment history discrepancies, or inaccurate educational qualifications.
Hence, it helps ensure that the candidate has the qualifications, experience, and character they claim to have. The most common types of background checks include:
-
Criminal background check
-
Employment history verification
-
Educational verification
-
Reference checks
Reference checks include contacting individuals who can comment on the candidate’s work ethic, skills, and performance in previous positions. These may include former supervisors, colleagues, or other professional contacts. Although not always a requirement, knowing something about the candidate’s personality and work habits is valuable.
2. Skills assessments
Skills assessments are important in the vetting process, as they are for roles requiring highly technical expertise or skill set. These may come through coding challenges, writing tests, case studies, and role-playing exercises. Gaining insight into a candidate’s skill sets and how they try to solve problems can only enhance your decision-making process.
Skills assessments help you to:
-
Accurately assess the candidate’s technical proficiency.
-
Ensure the candidate can apply their knowledge in real-world scenarios.
-
Identify any gaps in the candidate’s skill set early on.
A report by Gartner highlights 72% of employers believe that implementing skills assessments during the hiring process helps improve the quality of hires.
These assessments are particularly useful for software development, marketing, design, and finance jobs, where specific skills are necessary for success in the role.
5. Social media and online presence check
An SHRM survey found that 80% of employers use social media platforms to screen candidates during the hiring process. Candidates’ social media profiles can draw out information regarding a candidate’s behavior and character.
As much as respecting privacy boundaries and adhering to legal guidelines, reviewing a candidate’s social media profiles can reveal what they like, professionalism, and flags.
Look for:
-
Inappropriate or offensive posts.
-
Evidence of professionalism (e.g., LinkedIn endorsements, relevant work achievements).
-
Social media activity that aligns with the company’s values.
3. Conducting interviews
Once you have narrowed down your pool of candidates, interviews are the next step. This is the point at which you can assess a candidate’s communication skills, personality, and suitability for the role. You can carry out various kinds of interviews:
-
Phone screening: This is an initial, brief conversation to understand the candidate’s qualifications and enthusiasm for the role.
-
Video interview: A more detailed interview allows you to evaluate the candidate’s behavior, problem-solving, technical skills and how well they align with the job requirements.
6. Job offer and onboarding
position, extend the offer for the job. When offering, specify salary, benefits, job responsibilities, and start date. At this point, if the offer has been accepted, take action to implement the onboarding process.
Onboarding includes:
-
Introducing the new hire to the company culture, policies, and procedures.
-
Setting up their workspace, equipment, and tools.
-
Providing necessary training to ensure they succeed in the role.
Effective onboarding helps ensure a smooth transition and improves employee retention rates.
Best practices for employee vetting
Best practices in vetting employees ensure uniformity, fairness, and effectiveness in the recruitment process. The best practices ensure that risks are reduced for the human resource personnel while increasing candidate selection and staying within legal bounds.
1. Be consistent
​Ensure that your vetting process is consistent for all candidates. This makes the process fairer and reduces the risk of potential legal issues arising from discriminatory practices. Structured interviews, standardized background checks, and clear job descriptions help maintain consistency.
2. Respect privacy and legal guidelines
Be careful with privacy laws and regulations. Background checks must be done only after proper notice to candidates for whom the checks will be done and consent. Local labor laws, such as criminal record or credit information usage, must be considered when conducting background checks.
3. Use technology and automation
Using HR software and background check platforms can streamline the vetting process. These tools can help automate tasks like resume screening, background checks, and interview scheduling, making the process faster and more efficient.
4. Involve multiple stakeholders
Involve different team members in vetting, including hiring managers, team leaders, and HR professionals. This ensures that the decision is well-rounded and considers various perspectives on the candidate’s suitability for the role.
5. Always keep records
Maintain accurate records of the vetting process, including interview notes, background check results, and decisions made. It is essential for future reference and compliance with regulations in case of audits.
6. Be transparent with candidates
Be transparent about your vetting process. Let candidates know what the steps are and the timelines for each. This builds trust and helps candidates prepare for what to expect.
Common pitfalls to avoid in employee vetting
Vetting, though, is an important recruitment process component; several usual mistakes will undermine it. Not recognizing a red flag, overlooking potential bias, and failing to cover essential checks can lead to pricey hiring mistakes.
Overlooking red flags
Do not ignore red flags in your background checks. If one candidate has the most fantastic qualification, do not forget the criminal record or an inexplicable employment gap that calls for further investigation.
Bias in screening
Avoid bias when reviewing resumes or conducting interviews. Ensure that your decisions are based on qualifications, experience, and suitability for the role rather than personal opinions or stereotypes.
Not verifying claims
Verify a candidate’s qualifications, experience, and background at all times. Many false claims on resumes come to more employers’ notice than anyone realizes.
Conclusion
Employee vetting is a critical process of hiring that helps protect your organization from risks and enables you to hire the best. Through structured vetting processes and adherence to best practices, you can streamline recruitment efforts, minimize hiring mistakes, and contribute to building a strong, reliable workforce. Remember, hiring is not just about filling a position; it’s about finding the right fit for your home, team or company culture.